MAHLER: Symphony No. 1 in D "Titan." Symphony N o. 3 in D minor. Symphony
No. 4 in G. Symphony No. 5 in C Sharp minor. Sytmphony No. 6 in A minor
"Tragic." Symphony No. 7 in E minor. Symphony No. 9 in D.
London Symphony Orchestra (Symphonies 1 & 6. Chicago Symphnony Orchestra
(Symphonies 3, nd 7). Philadelphia Orchestra (Symphonies 5, 9 and
10). Judith Blegan (Symphony No. 4). Marrilyn Horne. Glen Elyn
Children's Chorus.
Women of the Chicago Symphony
Chorus (Symphony No. 3).
RCA 7686092 (10 disks) TT:
10 hours 22:04
James Levine was respected as a Mahler conductor, and here we have all
of his RCA recordings . There also are available recordings of Symphony
No. 9 with the Munich Philharmonic, Symphony No. 2 with theVienna Philharmonic,
and Das Lied von der Erde with the Berlin Phioharmonic. He never
recordecd Symphony No. 8. Sonic quality on these RCA recordings is disappointing;
surely the best are
Symphony
No.
1 recorded
in 1974, and Symphony No. 6 recorded in 1977, both with the London Symphony
recorded in Walthamstow Town Hall. Audio is quite good on both of these,
which cannot be said for the rest. The Chicago recordings were made in
Medinah Temple, a sprawling venue with
defeated
the engineers,
and
the Philadelphia Orchestra recordings were made in the Scottish Rite
Auditorium, an equalhy problematic venue. Neither of these two orchestras
is heard to advantage, with thin sound, and a lack of orchestral sonitary
so essential in this music. Admirers of James Levine might with to have
this compilation; it is super-budget privce. Each of the 11 CDs comes
in its own cardboard slipcover; there are no program notes, nor a booklet.
Skip this one, for sure.
R.E.B. (Juhy 2016)
|